Illegal Immigrant Deported After Living in the US for 30 Years, But Who Is To Blame?

Illegal Immigrant Deported After Living in the US for 30 Years, But Who Is To Blame?

Our nation's leaders have played politics on immigration reform for too long, and it results in heartbreaking circumstances, including family breakups.

News is breaking this morning of the terribly sad story of Jorge Garcia, a 39-year-old illegal immigrant and father of two, who has been living in the US for the past thirty years.  Garcia, who worked as a landscaper, said goodbye to his wife, daughter and son at Detroit Metropolitan Airport, escorted by two immigration agents from the federal government.

This story is sure to be played out across the media, both mainstream and social, as another case of the dictatorial Trump Administration ripping babies from the arms of mothers and tossing them over the already-built portions of the wall between the US and Mexico, and leaving them to fend for themselves.

But a closer look tells a quite different story.  Garcia was brought to the US by his parents, also illegal immigrants, at the age of 10, according to reports.  He appears to have led a quiet life, with no criminal record.  He met and married his wife, Cindy, who is a retired auto worker and a citizen of the US, fifteen years ago.

While attempting to gain legal status in 2005, Garcia was flagged for deportation.  Since that time, he has received numerous stays of removal, but he was too old to qualify for “Dreamer” status under the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) policy, designed to protect children of illegal immigrants.

In other words, Garcia was figuratively kicked down the road by the previous administration’s policies of not enforcing immigration laws on the books, and now that the Trump Administration has decided to enforce the laws, Garcia becomes the new face of government cruelty for immigration advocates.

Sadly, had the laws been followed in the first place, Garcia would very likely be living in Michigan with his family and all of this would be behind him by now.  That begs the question, which was the harsher punishment, allowing him to remain in the US, constantly looking over his shoulder for ICE agents, knowing the time was coming at any point in the last 15 years, or finally being held accountable and seeking to resolve the issue?

From all appearances, Garcia is the kind of immigrant most people would welcome into the US; hardworking, law abiding, and a family man.  But the fact remains, his family committed a crime by coming here illegally, and bringing him with them, and continued to commit the crime by living here undocumented.

That may not be a crime on par with joining a gang and murdering innocent citizens, but is a crime nevertheless.  And Garcia should be willing to accept the responsibility for his actions, maybe not as a 10-year-old, but as an adult years later.  He should have done so years ago, and implemented steps to gain US citizenship, even if it included deportation and applying legally.

The bigger crime is the fact that our government has failed repeatedly to address the issues of illegal immigration through legislation. Instead of passing laws to fix the problems, decrees were issued to postpone enforcement, or officials even chose to just ignore the laws currently on the books altogether, leaving generations of undocumented aliens in limbo, fear, and uncertainty.

And if the laws aren’t changed, sooner or later, someone will enforce them, and that is what brought us to this situation at the Detroit airport.

It is a terrible thing to see a family separated, but it is also a terrible thing to selective enforcement of immigration laws based on a political philosophy.  This problem can be solved with bi-partisan efforts.  Everybody may not get everything they want, but it can be improved to allow people like Jorge Garcia to become valuable American citizens.

But as long as immigration reform gets treated like a political football, there will be thousands upon thousands of Jorge Garcia stories in the news.  That, truly, is a sad, sad story.

Be social, please share!



  1. Michael says

    You talk as though this is some bi-partisan failure but it’s not. A family was torn apart because of this current administration, period.

    You talk of breaking the law as though it’s inherently bad. Recall that less than a century ago it was illegal for a black man to marry a white woman. 250 years ago, it was against the law for colonists to defy the crown. Sometimes the law is unjust, and we all have a moral obligation to disobey unjust laws, else tyranny will reign and we can’t move forward.

    To say the failure is on part of the previous administration is baloney, else why didn’t the current administration just repeal those unjust laws? Furthermore, looking back, it’s been only one party adamantly blocking immigration reform for the past decade.

    • says

      Thanks for reading my comments and also for your well-thought reply. I do believe immigration reform, and thus the situation with the Garcia family, is a bi-partisan problem because both parties have enjoyed majority positions over the last few decades and failed to pass any meaningful legislation on their watch. Mr. Garcia’s story itself spans over both Democrat and Republican administrations. I also must disagree with the comment that we have a moral obligation to disobey unjust laws, arguing instead we have a moral obligation to change or abolish unjust laws, as was done in the cases you present. Who is to decide which laws are unjust and should be disobeyed? Can the individual decide which laws they feel are just and ignore the rest? No, it is the responsibility of our elected representatives to repeal any unjust laws. The President does not have the power to write or repeal laws, but the Executive does have the responsibility for the enforcement of the law. My point is that had previous administrations taken their enforcement responsibilities seriously, perhaps Congress would have taken its responsibilities to reform the laws seriously as well. Thanks again for taking your time to read.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *