Sophie Vergara had a big night at Monday’s Emmy awards. Her show, Modern Family, cleaned up when it came to statues, and Vergara herself got a piece of the spotlight later in the show (though not without controversy). Afterwards, it was off to HBO’s Emmy after-party, where she spun around the room with Dancing with the Stars‘s Derek Hough to the tune of “Footloose.” Unfortunately, feet weren’t the only thing getting loose – Vergara’s nipple wanted a piece of the spotlight as well.

Vergara, in a strapless Roberto Cavalli gown, was whisked onto the floor as soon as Hough heard the song come on. The two apparently enjoyed their time as the centers of attention, one source tells Us Weekly:

“It was a full five minutes of him spinning her around the dance floor,” the observer noted. “No one could quite believe what they were seeing,” the eyewitness recalls, “nor were they able to take their eyes off of it.”

Vergara danced the night away, with both Hough and her costars at various party spots. Boyfriend Joe Manganiello was absent, though Vergara was seen sending text messages and pics to someone throughout the evening.